By Arthur 
Emerson Romero thrived as a deaf actor during Hollywood’s silent film era, performing stunts and starring in over 20 short films under the stage name Tommy Albert. When “talkies” revolutionized cinema in 1927, deaf performers like Romero suddenly found themselves excluded from the industry they once called home. Despite this devastating career setback, Romero refused to accept defeat. Instead, he pioneered the first captioned films in 1947, significantly transforming accessibility for deaf audiences and permanently changing movie history. His groundbreaking work creating primitive captions by cutting film strips and inserting text frames laid the foundation for modern captioning technology we take for granted today. Furthermore, his advocacy extended beyond film, encompassing inventions like the Vibralarm and extensive community outreach that continues to impact deaf culture worldwide.
Early Life and the Onset of Deafness
The story of Emerson Irving Romero began on August 19, 1900, in the vibrant city of Havana, Cuba 123. His early years were shaped by privilege and comfort as he was born into a wealthy family whose fortune came from exporting sugar to the United States 4. As the second of three sons, young Romero enjoyed the benefits of his family’s prosperity and cultural heritage.
Born in Havana, Cuba in 1900
Emerson’s early childhood in Cuba was relatively short-lived but formative. His parents provided him with all the advantages their social standing could afford, setting the stage for what they hoped would be a prosperous future. The turn of the century in Cuba represented a time of significant change, with the island having recently gained independence from Spain while developing complex economic ties with the United States. The Romero family’s sugar exporting business placed them at the intersection of these international relations.
Losing his hearing due to whooping cough
The trajectory of Emerson’s life changed dramatically at the age of six when he contracted whooping cough 12233. This highly contagious respiratory infection, known for its distinctive “whooping” sound, led to severe complications for young Romero. Among the long-term effects of this illness, the most significant was irreversible hearing loss 4.
The illness progressed until Emerson became completely deaf 4. This profound loss might have limited his opportunities in early 20th century society, but his parents refused to allow his deafness to determine his future. Rather than viewing his condition as an insurmountable obstacle, the Romero family sought solutions that would enable their son to thrive despite this unexpected challenge.
Education at Wright Oral School in New York
Determined to provide their son with the best possible education, Emerson’s parents made the momentous decision to send him to the United States 3. In 1907, just a year after losing his hearing, seven-year-old Emerson was enrolled at the Wright Oral School in New York City 233. This institution, founded by John Dutton Wright in 1902, specialized in teaching deaf children to speak 4.
From 1907 to 1915, Romero resided at the Wright Oral School, immersing himself in an educational environment specifically designed for deaf students 134. The school’s approach focused on oralism—teaching deaf children to communicate through speech rather than sign language. Throughout his eight years at the institution, Emerson developed remarkable communication skills.
His education yielded impressive results. Romero gained excellent command of both spoken and written English through speech reading techniques 4. Additionally, he learned finger spelling and basic sign language, likely from interactions with his classmates rather than formal instruction 4. Perhaps most remarkably, Emerson maintained his native Spanish language skills throughout his education 4.
This comprehensive education provided Romero with exceptional communication abilities that would later prove invaluable in his diverse career paths. His multilingual capabilities and adaptability demonstrated early on the resilience and determination that would characterize his approach to overcoming barriers throughout his life.
Breaking into Silent Films
After completing his education, Emerson Romero ventured into the professional world, initially securing employment at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York 25. This position provided stability, yet his career was about to take an unexpected turn toward the silver screen.
Joining his brother’s film company
Emerson’s life changed course when his older brother Dorian established the Pan-American Film Corporation in Cuba 26. Recognizing his younger brother’s potential, Dorian actively encouraged Emerson to consider acting as a profession 25. This fraternal nudge proved pivotal in launching Romero’s unexpected journey into cinema.
The transition from banking to filmmaking began with Romero starring in a full-length feature written by his brother titled A Yankee in Havana 26. Yet Romero’s contributions extended well beyond acting. He immersed himself in multiple aspects of production—shooting footage on location, editing films, and even writing subtitles 25. This hands-on approach gave him a comprehensive understanding of filmmaking that would serve him throughout his career.
Adopting the stage name Tommy Albert
As Romero’s presence in films grew, his distributors made a significant request that reflected the cultural attitudes of 1920s America. They suggested he adopt a “more American-like” name to increase his marketability 21. Consequently, Emerson Romero became “Tommy Albert” professionally 222, a stage name that would appear in credits across his filmography.
This name change illustrated the complex navigation of identity that many performers from immigrant backgrounds experienced in early Hollywood. Despite this professional rebranding, Romero maintained his authentic self behind the scenes, continuing to develop his multifaceted skills in the industry.
Performing stunts and acting in over 20 short films
Between 1926 and 1928, Romero’s career flourished as he appeared in more than 24 two-reel short comedies 212. His filmography included titles such as Beachnuts, The Cat’s Meow, Great Guns, Hen-Pecked in Morocco, Sappy Days, and a remake of Tillie’s Punctured Romance 217.
Notably, Romero performed all his own stunt work 215, showcasing his athletic abilities through slapstick falls and exaggerated physical comedy. His performances featured “rolling stunts… exaggerated collapses,” and other physically demanding actions typical of silent film comedy 2. With his athletic build and natural charisma, he embodied the physicality required for silent film success 2.
Beyond stunts, Romero handled his own makeup 21 and constantly sought to improve filmmaking techniques 2, demonstrating his comprehensive approach to the craft. Throughout his cinematic career, he worked alongside established talents, including renowned comedian W.C. Fields 261.
The silent film era provided an ideal medium for Romero’s talents. In an environment where dialog was expressed through facial expressions, body movement, and intertitles rather than spoken words, his deafness presented no barrier to participation 2. The visual nature of storytelling in silent cinema created a uniquely level playing field where Romero could showcase his expressive abilities and physical prowess.
Although he never achieved mainstream stardom, Romero’s presence in silent films marked a significant milestone for deaf representation in early cinema 2. His participation demonstrated that visual storytelling could transcend auditory limitations, allowing talented performers from all backgrounds to contribute to the emerging art form.
The End of an Era: How Talkies Changed Everything
The silent film era represented a golden period for deaf people in America—a unique time when they could participate equally with hearing audiences in enjoying mainstream entertainment. However, this equality would prove short-lived.
Introduction of sound films in 1927
Everything changed in 1927 with the premiere of The Jazz Singer, widely considered the pivotal film in cinema’s transition to sound 3. Warner Brothers’ groundbreaking production starred Al Jolson, whose character not only sang but also engaged in spoken dialog 8. The film’s success convinced studio executives that audiences desired to hear actors speak, triggering a rapid industry-wide transformation.
Within just three years of The Jazz Singer’s release, virtually all new Hollywood productions had abandoned silent filmmaking 3. This swift shift wasn’t merely a technical evolution—it fundamentally altered the art form itself. As one contemporary observer noted, silent films communicated visually through “pictures that moved,” whereas talkies relied on spoken dialog to convey plot, ideas, and emotions 3.
The essence of silent cinema had been profoundly visual. Silent actors like Charlie Chaplin could convey complex emotions through “shrugs, smiles, solemnities, insinuations, blandishments” 3. This visual storytelling created what historian John Schuchman called “the only time in the cultural history of the United States when deaf persons could participate in one of the performing arts with their hearing peers on a comparatively equal basis” 39.
Exclusion of deaf actors from mainstream cinema
Once sound became dominant, deaf actors were summarily excluded from mainstream cinema 410. Studios abandoned intertitles, which had previously made films accessible to everyone regardless of hearing ability 4. Moreover, the filmmaking process itself transformed dramatically—actors now needed to stand still while speaking to ensure microphones captured their voices clearly 8.
The cultural attitudes of the era revealed themselves in how silent films were disparaged as “dummies” or “dumbies” after talkies emerged—terms strikingly similar to slurs directed at deaf people 311. This normalization extended beyond terminology; advertisements for theater sound systems boasted that movies had been “cured of their deafness” or taught to “talk like living people” 3.
For deaf audience members, the advent of talkies meant an abrupt end to equal access. They were effectively “shut out of enjoying movies” 49. Without captioning technology or other accommodations, deaf viewers would remain excluded from mainstream cinema for decades 12.
Romero’s return to banking and factory work
The industry transformation hit Emerson Romero particularly hard. His flourishing film career came to “an immediate and abrupt halt” 10. In the fall of 1928, with performance opportunities vanishing, Romero returned to New York and resumed employment at his previous workplace—the Federal Reserve Bank 410.
His professional path took several turns throughout subsequent years. During World War II, Romero worked as a sheet metal worker at Republic Aviation Corporation 2. This career shift was not uncommon among deaf individuals at the time, as many found employment in aviation factories where their immunity to noise disturbance proved advantageous 2.
Throughout these professional transitions, Romero remained actively engaged with the deaf community in New York City. In 1934, alongside friends John Funk and Sam Block, he established the Theater Guild of the Deaf 1. This organization created a space for deaf performers who had been excluded from mainstream entertainment—a creative response to Hollywood’s rejection.
Romero’s resilience in the face of career disruption foreshadowed his later innovations. Far from accepting the new limitations imposed by talkies, he would eventually pioneer techniques to make sound films accessible to deaf audiences—setting in motion changes that would eventually transform movie accessibility forever.
Pioneering Captions for the Deaf
Forced out of his acting career, Emerson Romero refused to accept that deaf audiences would permanently lose access to cinema. His innovative spirit led him to create solutions that would ultimately transform film accessibility for generations to come.
Founding the Theater Guild of the Deaf
In 1934, Romero channeled his theatrical talents into establishing the Theater Guild of the Deaf alongside friends John Funk and Sam Block 41. This groundbreaking organization provided a creative outlet for deaf performers throughout the next two decades. Throughout this period, Romero remained at the center of activities, both acting in and directing numerous productions 41. The Guild fostered a vibrant deaf arts community in New York City at a time when mainstream entertainment had closed its doors.
Creating the first captioned film in 1947
Vis-à-vis his commitment to accessibility, Romero took a historic step in 1947 by developing the first captioned film 413. Without government funding or industry support, he purchased various films with his own money and began experimenting with captioning techniques 2. His method involved physically cutting film strips and inserting text frames between scenes—analogous to the title cards familiar from silent films 41. This painstaking process required him to transcribe dialog and then create subtitle cards that could be spliced between frames 2.
Challenges with early captioning techniques
Nevertheless, Romero’s pioneering technique faced substantial limitations. The visual quality of his captioned films was deliberately poor to prevent unauthorized copying 41. Furthermore, his method rendered the films’ soundtracks unusable for hearing viewers 41. Working essentially alone in what might have been a garage or small office, Romero struggled with the crude nature of his technique 2. In essence, he confronted the pervasive attitude that deaf audiences were too small a minority to justify the expense of accommodation 2.
Inspiring future government-funded captioning programs
Without a doubt, Romero’s determination laid crucial groundwork for future accessibility. His efforts caught the attention of Edmund Burke Boatner, superintendent of the American School for the Deaf 41. Together with educator J. Pierre Rakow, Boatner studied Romero’s methods and developed more practical captioning approaches 14. These efforts culminated in the establishment of Captioned Films for the Deaf (CFD) 1514, which ultimately secured federal funding through the Captioned Film Act 14. Thus, Romero’s homemade captioning experiments became the catalyst for government-supported accessibility programs that continue to benefit millions today 2.
Beyond Film: Romero’s Broader Contributions
Emerson Romero’s ingenuity stretched far beyond his pioneering work in film captioning. Throughout his life, he developed numerous solutions to everyday challenges faced by deaf individuals.
Inventions like the Vibralarm and other assistive devices
Beyond cinema, Romero created practical devices to overcome communication barriers. His most notable invention, the Vibralarm, helped deaf individuals wake up independently through vibrations rather than sound. This bed-shaking alarm represented just one of many assistive technologies he developed to enhance daily life for the deaf community.
Apart from alarm systems, he designed visual doorbell indicators and telephone adaptations that transformed sound-based signals into visual cues. These innovations addressed practical challenges long before mainstream accessibility became a consideration.
Writing for Deaf publications and community outreach
In fact, Romero’s contributions to deaf culture extended into journalism and advocacy. He regularly wrote articles for prominent deaf publications, sharing insights on technological developments and cultural issues affecting the community.
Throughout his lifetime, he remained deeply committed to deaf organizations, often traveling to give presentations about his innovations and experiences. Primarily through the Theater Guild of the Deaf and other community groups, he mentored younger deaf individuals, fostering a spirit of innovation and self-determination that outlived his direct contributions.
As well as his technical innovations, his persistent advocacy helped shift public perception about deaf capabilities during a time when deaf individuals faced substantial discrimination.
Conclusion
Emerson Romero’s remarkable journey exemplifies how adversity can spark innovation that changes history. Pushed from his thriving silent film career by the advent of “talkies,” he nevertheless refused to accept the exclusion of deaf audiences from cinema. His homemade captioning technique, though primitive by today’s standards, undoubtedly laid the foundation for all modern captioning technology.
The impact of his work extends far beyond his lifetime. What began as Romero cutting film strips in a small workspace eventually evolved into federally-funded programs and laws mandating accessibility. Consequently, millions of deaf and hard-of-hearing individuals worldwide now enjoy equal access to entertainment that was once denied to them.
Throughout his life, Romero demonstrated exceptional versatility. From silent film actor to banker, from factory worker to inventor, he constantly adapted while never abandoning his commitment to deaf accessibility. His Vibralarm and other assistive devices further demonstrated his practical problem-solving approach to barriers faced by deaf individuals.
Perhaps most significantly, Romero challenged prevailing attitudes about deafness during an era when accessibility was rarely considered. Despite facing rejection from mainstream cinema, he created alternative spaces through the Theater Guild of the Deaf while simultaneously developing technical solutions to overcome barriers.
Romero’s legacy reminds us that accessibility isn’t merely about technology—it’s about persistence, creativity, and refusing to accept exclusion. Though his name might not be widely recognized outside deaf history, his pioneering work forever transformed how deaf people experience media. The captioning technology we take for granted today exists because one determined man decided that everyone deserved equal access to the magic of movies.
References
[1] – https://deafhistory.eu/index.php/component/zoo/item/emerson-romero
[2] – https://www.cbc.ca/radio/q/friday-oct-9-2020-bahamas-hrishikesh-hirway-and-more-1.5755895/how-a-deaf-silent-film-actor-pioneered-closed-captioning-1.5755964
[3] – https://blog.oup.com/2017/07/silent-movies-deafness/
[4] – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emerson_Romero
[5] – https://www.timebulletin.com/interesting-and-fun-facts-about-emerson-romero-a-cuban-american-silent-film-actor-and-activist/
[6] – https://en.cibercuba.com/noticias/2024-09-20-u1-e129488-s27061-nid288747-google-homenajea-emerson-romero-actor
[7] – https://www.jagranjosh.com/general-knowledge/google-doodle-celebrating-emerson-romero-1726742124-1
[8] – https://www.wonderstruckthebook.com/essay_silent-to-sound.htm
[9] – https://dcmp.org/learn/static-assets/nadh211.pdf
[10] – https://generalist.academy/2020/11/11/first-closed-captioning/
[11] – https://www.watershed.co.uk/articles/130-years-deaf-people-and-moving-image-coming-full-circle
[12] – https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/k2ob9w/how_did_deaf_people_react_to_the_introduction_of/
[13] – https://ecocaptions.com/blog/history-of-closed-captions
[14] – https://captionlabs.com/blog/first-deaf-hero-in-closed-captioning-history/
[15] – https://dcmp.org/learn/80-captioning-for-deaf-people-an-historical-overview